As we finish with our unit on Much Ado About Nothing, consider what stereotypes (racial, class, gender, etc.) are present in the play and how they effect your interpretation of the events portrayed. Do you think Shakespeare believed in the stereotypes he presented or do you feel he was attempting to teach his audience a lesson about misjudging others or about forcing people to conform to tradition? Your intial POST is due on 1-17-08 and your comments on other's blogs are due on 1-23-08.
Nearly all of Shakespeare's plays contain some form of a stereotype. This play focuses on the stereotype that all bastards are evil. Either your legitimate or your existance is worthless. Don John the Bastard is the villain of the play. I believe that Shakespeare is using hyperbole in order to show people just how far we go with our stereotypes. First, Don John attempts to hurt his brother by telling Claudio how Don Pedro has stolen Hero, "I heard him swear his affection" (II.1.160). Don John's initial plan fails, so he devises a scheme to insult Hero. He tells Claudio that she is disloyal, and lays out a plan so that Claudio will believe it, "Even she--Leonato's Hero, your Hero, every man's Hero" (III.2.95-96). Shakespeare is clearly making fun of our sterotypes.
Shakespeare shows us what our prejudging does when he shows how Don John's treatment leads to his behavior. Don John is always treated as a lesser and he seeks revenge for this treatment. Perhaps if Pedro/Pedro's father/Claudio... treated him better (as an equal), none of this would have happened. Shakespeare does is this in the Merchant of Venice too, where Shylock is so mistreated that he is driven to demand a pound of flesh from a man who could not pay what he owed. In this play, and in most of his plays, Shakespeare exagerates our stereotypes so that we may see our faults.
4 comments:
Silas,
Way to go, elaborating on Don John, one of the lesser known characters in MAAN...how befitting. He's a bastard, so don't write much about him. Anyway, he does play an intricate role in the plot; he was responsible for the entire mishap with Hero, which changes the cheerful Act 1-3 into a tragic Act 4. "Your either legitimate or your existence is worthless"...funny! However, as for Keanu Reeve's acting, that is worthy of judgement!
Yes. Way to go with the character of Don John. He didn't really pass through my mind as a character to talk about and how he is judged in very stereotypical ways.
I agree with your statement about how Shakespeare uses Don John as a way to poke fun at the world's sterotypes of people.
Very nice work.
your point about John the bastard is very interesting. I never would have thought of it. Not only do you bring up an aspect I didn't think about, but you justify it very well. Nice work.
Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the Servidor, I hope you enjoy. The address is http://servidor-brasil.blogspot.com. A hug.
Post a Comment